(FinalCall.com)�If
he knew, why didn�t he do something to prevent it? If he didn�t know,
why didn�t he know?
Those are the questions echoing across the country as
the nation debates recent revelations that President Bush was warned
that terrorists would hijack domestic U.S. flights but did very little
to prevent it.
Ultimately, four planes were hijacked on Sept. 11,
2001�two of them crashing into the World Trade Center, one into the U.S.
Pentagon, and one into a field in Pennsylvania. Thousands of lives were
lost.
"Had I known they were going to use airplanes to kill, I
would have done everything in my power to protect the American people,"
President Bush told the nation in response to mounting criticism of his
administration. He said the warnings were vague, but critics say there
were enough of them from different agencies and from across the country
that should have sparked attention and action.
One memo last July from FBI agent Kenneth Williams in
Phoenix advised the agency to look into the number of Middle Eastern men
in certain flight training schools across the country. Foreknowledge of
these warnings is one reason observers believe the government was so
quick in identifying the alleged hijackers and coming out with a
scenario of how the hijackings happened.
But, "any time anybody suggests or implies to the
American people that this president had specific information that could
have prevented the attacks on our country on September 11, that crosses
the lines," said White House spokesman Ari Fleisher.
The controversy emerged May 15 with the leaking of
information to CBS News. Tyrone Powers, a former FBI counterintelligence
agent who now teaches at Anne Arundel Community College in Maryland,
surmised that the leaks probably came from the FBI in order to deflect
criticism and spread the blame.
In one sense, the nature of the FBI and CIA facilitated
a break down in intelligence because the agencies ofttimes don�t share
information, he said. One reason is they both have to compete for
funding from Congress.
Until the appointment of former Pennsylvania Gov. Tom
Ridge as director of the Office of Homeland Security, "they didn�t have
a common person to report to," he said.
Gov�t wasn�t blindsided
Even if the president didn�t expect the planes to be
used as missiles, a number of observers suggest the Bush administration
knew something was going to happen�something that was needed to divert
attention from other issues pressing his administration.
"They didn�t know that it would be of this scale because
of the government�s arrogance, but they were willing to let something
happen," charged Dr. Powers.
Prior to Sept. 11, the mood in the country was to
restrict the powers of the FBI and CIA because of abuses by the agencies
and embarrassing cases where agents leaked information to foreign
governments, Mr. Powers said. In addition, the country was debating
whether Mr. Bush stole the 2000 presidential election and the
government�s refusal to participate in the UN Racism Conference in South
Africa.
As a result of Sept. 11, the powers of the intelligence
agencies have been enhanced and draconian laws have been passed that
hack away at civil liberties, he said.
Since Sept. 11, President Bush�s popularity rating has
skyrocketed. His commanding stand and prosecution of the "War on
Terrorism" swept away any criticism of his administration. In fact,
critics of the Bush administration post 9/11 have been viewed as
"unpatriotic."
A
prime example is the scathing attack on Rep. Cynthia McKinney (D-Ga.),
the Black congresswoman who earlier this year suggested during a radio
program in California that ample warning of an attack was given, and
that the Bush family�s business interests and the military industrial
complex have been the main beneficiaries of the war on terror. Her call
for a full investigation of what went wrong and why was ridiculed in
newspapers and Georgia Sen. Zel Miller (D) called her accusations
"dangerous, loony and irresponsible."
"I was derided by the White House, right wing talk
radio, and spokespersons for the military-industrial complex as a
conspiracy theorist," a vindicated Rep. McKinney proclaimed in a
statement. "Even my patriotism was questioned because I dared to suggest
that Congress should conduct a full and complete investigation into the
most disastrous intelligence failure in American history.
"Today�s revelations that the administration, and
President Bush, were given months of notice that a terrorist attack was
a distinct possibility points out the critical need for a full and
complete congressional investigation. The Bush Administration has been
engaged in a conspiracy of silence. Ever since I came to Congress in
1992, there are those who have been trying to silence my voice. I�ve
been told to �sit down and shut up� over and over again. Well, I won�t
sit down and I won�t shut up until the full and unvarnished truth is
placed before the American people," she said.
Indeed, the idea of airplanes being used as bombs was
not a new one. Japanese kamikaze pilots were used during World War II.
Most recently, plots to slam planes into the Eiffel Tower in Paris, and
even an economic summit in Genoa, Italy, attended by President Bush last
year, have been thwarted.
Furthermore, an analysis prepared for U.S. intelligence
warned that Osama bin Laden�s operatives could hijack an airliner and
fly it into government buildings like the Pentagon.
"Suicide bomber(s) belonging to al-Qaida�s Martyrdom
Battalion could crash-land an aircraft packed with high explosives (C-4
and semtex) into the Pentagon, the headquarters of the Central
Intelligence Agency (CIA), or the White House,�� the September 1999
report said.
White House spokesman Mr. Fleischer dismissed the report
as a psychological study that was not written by U.S. intelligence.
Media culpable
The media also has come under increased criticism for
"not asking the hard questions" subsequent to Sept. 11, with CBS News
anchor Dan Rather being one of the more vocal critics of his own
profession.
Speaking on British Broadcasting Corp. (BBC) television
recently, the noted anchor described the U.S. media�s failure to pursue
the truth as "patriotism run amok."
"What we are talking about here�whether one wants to
recognize it or not, or call it by its proper name or not�is a form of
self-censorship," Mr. Rather said on Newsnight TV show. "It
starts with a feeling of patriotism within oneself. It carries through
with a certain knowledge that the country as a whole�and for all the
right reasons�felt and continues to feel this surge of patriotism within
themselves.
"And one finds oneself saying, �I know the right
question, but you know what, this is not exactly the right time to ask
it,� " he said.
Mr. Rather drew the surprising comparison of the
situation in the United States to what existed during apartheid in South
Africa.
"It is an obscene comparison. But you know there was a
time in South Africa that people would put flaming tires around peoples�
necks if they dissented," he said. "And in some ways the fear is that
you will be necklaced here, you will have a flaming tire of lack of
patriotism put around your neck. Now it is that fear that keeps
journalists from asking the toughest of the tough questions. ... And
again, I am humbled to say, I do not except myself from this criticism."
Popular Chicago radio talk show host Cliff Kelly, who
also is vice president of the Illinois American Civil Liberties Union,
told The Final Call that revelations that the president was
forewarned and Mr. Rather�s confession vindicates the critics of the
government and press who have been vilified for their "patriotism."
"People who are patriots must be in eternal vigilance of
watching the government. You must remember that the original patriots of
this country overthrew the government. The press, which is the only
business that has a constitutional mandate, need to keep the pressure on
as [Bush] tries to take attention away from this," he said.
Political commentator and syndicated columnist Earl
Ofari Hutchinson and Mr. Powers are leery of the Bush administration�s
continuing efforts to put over its domestic agenda�tax cuts, curtailing
civil liberties, and orchestrate Mr. Bush�s re-election in 2004.
Mr. Hutchinson warned that Republicans continue to
"manufacture terrorist threats" for domestic political purposes. None of
the imminent attacks have happened, he said.
But Mr. Powers said "you don�t have to be Dionne
Warwick" to predict another attack.
"The cells are still here and they have separate
operations. And we�ve closed down the borders, so they can�t get out,"
he said.
--30--