Image
of Africa still tainted in Gates' documentaryby
Ahmed-Rufai
From Carter G. Woodson to Marcus Garvey, from the 1950s when Paul
Robeson and W. E. B. DuBois and the Council on African Affairs fought
to end colonialism in Africa, to the present Summit on Africa,
Africanists and others interested in a positive image for Africa have
strived to correct the Western image of Africa. While most of that
negative image was portrayed by Hollywood and the white-controlled
media, the most recent attack on Africa�s image is more devastating
as it comes from "one of Africa�s own."
In the six-part series "Wonders of the African World,"
which aired on PBS, Dr. Gates repeatedly accused his African hosts of
selling his ancestors into slavery but never once pointed out the role
of Europeans and others, particularly in the Atlantic slave trade. In
his final remarks, Dr. Gates blamed Africa�s current
"mess" on "the curse of slavery." While some
African ethnic groups did participate actively in the slave trade,
such a blanket statement denies the facts of other African groups who
never participated in any shape or form.
Dr. Henry Louis Gates, Jr., in the words of Dr. Gwendolyn Brooks
(not the poet) of Georgetown University, has "betrayed" the
initiatives that have been built on the images and positions on Africa
through the summit on Africa. Dr. Brooks, speaking at the recently
concluded 42nd annual meeting of the African Studies Association in
Philadelphia, said she thought the Gates series was going to be a
re-enforcement of the African positive image. Dr. Brooks said she is
"offended" by Dr. Gates� position as a scholar because of
his claims that slavery is only blamed on "African greed."
Speaking in the same vein, Dr. Molefi K. Asante of Temple
University, said the Gates series has put African and African American
activists "fifty years back," adding, "if a white man
had done what Gates did, we would have been enraged." Dr. Asante
said the series has freed "the initiator of European slavery and
the notion of Africans as chattel."
Dr. Jane MacDougal of Howard University condemned Dr. Gates�
pretense to speak for Black Americans when he spoke of African sales
of Blacks into slavery: "His refusal to mention Europe even once
in this trade gets them off the hook." She called for an open
letter to be sent to PBS and the BBC by the board of the African
Studies Association.
In reviewing Dr. Gates� position on slavery, African historians
recognized that failure of African countries, particularly scholars,
to speak of Africa�s role gave Mr. Gates the point he raised. One of
the elder statemen of African historiography, Professor Ade Ajayi of
the University of Ibadan, called on African scholars to accept the
challenge and to seriously study the impact of slavery on the
continent.
Since 1991, African countries, led by the late Moshood Abiola of
Nigeria, have campaigned for reparations for Africa and Africans in
the diaspora for centuries of colonialism and slavery. The recent
payment of more than $3.1 billion by German-based Volkswagen to Jews
who were forced to work for the company during World War II has
intensified this campaign. The Gates series, for not mentioning any
European or Jewish role throughout the series, is, therefore,
considered by many as aimed at taking the wind out of the reparations
movement. The interest of the Annenberg Foundation, which sponsored
Mr. Gates� series, is believed to be tied to such interest.
For Prof. Ali Mazrui and Sir Dudley Thompson of Jamaica, both
members of the Group of Eminent Persons on Reparations for the
Organization of African Unity, "Skip Gates� television series
virtually tells the world that the West has no case to answer.
Africans sold each other." This blanket indictment of an entire
continent, in Prof. Mazrui�s view, is the birth of "Black
Orientalism."
In responding to his critics, Mr. Gates defended his position by
listing the different experts he consulted in producing the series. He
did not say what suggestions they gave him and how he used those
suggestions in his travelogue.
|