With the successful cloning of a human embryo for stem cell research,
mankind now faces the controversial prospect of human life created in
the laboratory for study and then destruction.
Has science gone mad, or are mad scientists at work?
Massachusetts-based Advanced Cell Technology (ACT) announced their
unprecedented research, findings and intentions to a stunned medical
community Nov. 25.
The company�s spin on their macabre scientific experiment is that
they will "make lifesaving therapies for a wide range of human disease
conditions."
"These are exciting preliminary results," said Robert P. Lanza, M.D.,
vice president of Medical and Scientific Development at ACT. "This
work sets the stage for human therapeutic cloning as a potentially
limitless source of immune-compatible cells for tissue engineering and
transplantation medicine."
"Our intention is not to create cloned human beings, but rather to
make lifesaving therapies for a wide range of human disease conditions,
including diabetes, strokes, cancer, AIDS, and neurodegenerative
disorders such as Parkinson�s and Alzheimer�s disease."
Analysts who reviewed the firm�s work published in the current
Journal of Regenerative Medicine suggest ACT�s breakthrough is more
science gone mad, and a hype to create not a cure for disease but
possibly a new class of bio-billionaires through the sale of human
embryos.
Opponents worry about people being bred like livestock for profit and
"human beings sacrificed for spare parts or profit," said one critic.
The House has overwhelmingly passed legislation to stop the
experiments. But the Senate has yet to act.
This medical advance is not being received with welcome arms, and a
list of opponents to human embryo cloning is quickly growing. Even
President Bush came out against the announcement.
ACT plans to venture into stem cell research next. According to
representatives, they are not interested in cloning human beings.
"Human cloning is a hazardous, risky process and should never be used
to produce a human being," said ACT�s Ethics Board member, Ronald Green.
"We believe that reproductive cloning has potential risks to both mother
and fetus that make it unwarranted at this time," ACT scientists added
in an article to be published in Scientific American magazine
next January.
"And we support a restriction on cloning for reproductive purposes
until the safety and ethical issues surrounding it are resolved."
That statement, however, is insufficient to calm opponents who want
to see other types of research done to produce stem cells.
Concerned Women of America, a public policy group, contends that
cures are being found�through ethical research. Every week new
discoveries are announced, yet they receive no attention because they
are not controversial, the group said.
On Nov. 12, Japanese scientists reported that adult stem cells taken
from patients� own hip bones were used to repair heart damage.
Scientists at Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia reported on
Nov. 11 that they could convert adult human bone marrow cells into brain
cells in the laboratory.
Sandy Rios, president of Concerned Women for America, stated: "The
virtue of this latest announcement is that this method is supposed to be
�therapeutic.� Somehow that word is supposed to make us feel better
about using our offspring as disposable parts."
In a world where body parts, or organs are needed for transplantation
can be bought in poor countries, the line against human cloning should
be drawn now. There is too little respect for life to give profit-making
companies the chance to clone human beings.