The struggle of Black America for freedom, justice and
equality puts those Blacks who attain prominent government positions in
a precarious position. They must parrot the government�s foreign and
domestic policies, whether they agree with them or not.
That�s the position Secretary of State Colin Powell, a
descendant of African slaves, finds himself in today. After being told
that he could not participate in the UN World Conference Against Racism
being held Aug. 31-Sept. 7 in Durban, South Africa, Mr. Powell himself,
we are told, on Sept. 3 pulled the low-level delegation sent to the
conference to observe only.
Frustrated that many delegates persisted in pointing out
the aggression of the Israeli government against Palestinians, some of
whom wanted to equate Zionism with racism, Mr. Powell issued a statement
calling the delegation home.
Consider the irony. A man whose forefathers were
shackled, killed and worked to death for no pay to build this hemisphere
for European domination, is now in the position that he must call home a
delegation at a world conference called to discuss ways of redressing
the oppression his people have suffered.
The problem with representing a government as a member
of the oppressed is that if you disagree with the position you are
either pulled in line, or you are kicked out of the administration, and
possibly hounded out of elective office.
Mr. Powell had a brush with the Bush administration with
what he deemed a sensible approach to a problem, only to find out that
the boss didn�t feel the same.
Last February, while at the UN headquarters in New York,
Mr. Powell was holding out the possibility of diplomatic solutions to
problems between the U.S. and Iraq. He voiced support for a meeting
between Iraqi and UN officials, saying talking was always good and
expressing hope that Iraq would show a willingness to comply with UN
mandates. There was also a hint of a possible move toward ending
U.S.-led sanctions against Iraq. Mr. Powell was at the United Nations
talking peace and diplomacy Feb. 14. Two days later, the U.S. dropped
bombs on Iraq. Mr. Powell had to backpedal away from the diplomatic talk
and was facing formidable anger just before a planned visit to the
Middle East.
Still like a good soldier, he moved ahead with the Bush
administration�s battle plan for the Middle East.
The U.S. pullout from the UN conference has enraged many
people, including Black activists from the United States. Many of them
feel, including us, that the U.S. pull-out, while revealing to the world
the blind eye the U.S. government shows to Israeli injustice to
Palestinians, is really meant to pull the U.S. government away from any
discussion about giving Blacks in America reparations.
In preliminary discussions leading up to the conference,
the U.S. denounced activists and African governments who brought up the
issue of paying for the slave trade. The U.S. said it had worked out
that issue just before the conference started, but surprisingly now the
issue of Israelis discrimination against Palestinians is an issue she
can�t bear to discuss.
We don�t think so.
Secretary of State Colin Powell had to carry the
government�s position on the African Union. While that position
outwardly was supportive of what our brothers and sisters on the
continent are trying to do, we can never be sure of this government�s
motives or statements.
Secretary Powell could have bucked the administration
and insisted that the U.S. must participate in a conference that will
set the agenda for addressing racism and discrimination.
But if he did, he would no longer be secretary of state.
He made his decision.