it appeared that the major trend in the Black vote in the immediately
past elections was division, but that gave way in some races to
strategic voting and then to traditional patterns of unity.
First the division. We are now experiencing the second generation of
Black elected officials at the municipal level and since the first
generation of strong Black mayors has passed from the scene. And where
once Blacks were unified in their support of one person, now members of
city councils are challenging incumbent Black mayors. In short, the mood
is the equivalent of "everyone into the water."
An obvious example of this was the re-election bid of Houston�s
mayor, Lee Brown, who was not only challenged by a Republican Hispanic
candidate, Orlando Sanchez, but other Black members of the city council
as well. The result was that he failed to obtain 50 percent of the vote
and faces a run-off with Sanchez.
The next example was the narrow victory of Shirley Franklin in
Atlanta, the first Black female mayor-elect of that city. Franklin,
former chief aide to former Mayor Maynard Jackson, was a seasoned city
official. Yet a substantial field of candidates, including several city
council members, challenged her. She barely won 50 percent of the vote,
avoiding a run-off.
***
The mayor�s race in Detroit featured a generational divide when
31-year-old Black state legislator Kwame Kilpatrick, head of the Black
Legislative Caucus, ran against 70-year-old Gill Hill, the three-term
head of the Detroit City Council. Kilpatrick, son of Rep. Carolyn
Kilpatrick (D-Mich.), completed the generational change of the political
system in the city that has been underway since the passing of scion
Coleman Young by this solid consensus victory.
Finally, Jane Campbell, a white moderate Democrat, won election to be
the mayor of Cleveland, having defeated 37-year-old Raymond Pierce, who
is a Black former assistant secretary of education in the Clinton
administration. Campbell, who had a long record of service as a county
politician, was able to draw 27 percent of the Black vote which, coupled
with her strong support in the mixed and predominantly white wards, gave
her the victory.
Next, strategic voting. In the New York mayoral race, while a
post-election survey found that loser Mark Green, a Democrat, won 72
percent of the Black vote, Republican Michael Bloomberg won the race
with 15 percent of the Black vote. This was important because 41 percent
of those who voted for Green in the primary crossed over to support
Bloomberg in the General election�and many of them were Black. Part of
the reason was that it became public that Green�s operatives had a
meeting to discuss whether to stimulate more support from Jewish voters
by linking Green�s opponent in the Democratic primary election, Hispanic
candidate Fernando Ferrer to the Rev. Al Sharpton.
So Black Enterprise publisher Earl Graves took out a full-page
ad in the New York Amsterdam News, featuring other prominent
Black figures in New York, urging Blacks to support Bloomberg. It
worked. Not the so-called "Giuliani factor." Now Bloomberg, a former
liberal Democrat as late as last year, owes something to Blacks.
Nevertheless, the concern some have in New York is that the open racial
polarization in this election could spill over into the Democratic
primary for governor, in which Andrew Cuomo, Clinton�s former HUD
secretary, will be pitted against Carl McCall, the Black current state
comptroller.
Then, there was unity. One example of this was the racially polarized
mayoral race in Cincinnati, which was won by incumbent Republican
Charlie Lukens. Curtis Fuller, a Black city council member, challenged
him. Luken, who won the contest 55 percent to 45 percent, was expected
to have a tougher battle, since he had supported the white policeman who
killed an unarmed Black man, prompting several days of rebellion. Luken
looked upon this victory as a "vindication of his actions." But in a
city that is 60 percent white, only the western, heavily white part of
the city turned out strongly to vote for him. Black turnout was also
higher than usual, as Fuller won all six of the predominantly Black
wards in the city, while Lukens won all of the predominantly white
wards.
The outcome of the November elections showed that most of the
reaction of the Black vote was to local issues and candidates, with no
national theme. However, given the strong showing of Democrats, even in
the case of the victory of Republican Michael Bloomberg, the Black vote
was obviously crucial. George Bush tellingly stayed away from the
election, even where Republican Mark Early in Virginia faced an eventual
losing battle to "moderate" Democrat Mark Warner. And although he did
so, not wanting to spend his precious capital on losing causes, the
national crisis greatly overshadowed the elections. In so doing, it
robbed them of additional national themes that would have boosted
turnout and made the results more interesting than they were.
(Dr. Ron Walters is a political science professor at the University
of Maryland and co-author of the book "African American Leadership.")