(FinalCall.com)---Pro basketball prognosticators predict June 27 at least
four high schoolers stand a good chance of realizing a dream shared by
thousands of their peers: the coveted chance to play in the National
Basketball Association, after hearing their names called at this year�s
NBA draft at New York�s Madison Square Garden.
And even though three of the league�s top players, Kobe
Bryant, Kevin Garnett and Tracy McGrady are "baby ballers," who jumped
from high school courts to pro arenas, there is still the debate
about whether "kids" should make such moves.
One voice questioning the high school-to-pro-leap is the
man who made it all possible: Spencer Haywood. It was a Supreme Court
decision in the 1970s, that opened the door to the hardship draft, and
knocked out an NBA decision to keep him out of the league before he
finished college.
"Although I do understand the need to support families,
my intention was not to eventually eliminate players� skill
development," said Mr. Haywood, a former NBA star.
When he left the University of Detroit to play in the
then NBA-rival American Basketball Association, his mother was living on
$30-a week and his family was picking cotton in the Mississippi Delta.
He was one of nine children and needed to make money. At 19, he jumped
to the ABA, inking a six-year $1.9 million deal. When the NBA�s Seattle
Supersonics came calling, he wanted to sign. An NBA rule said no player
could be drafted before his four years of college eligibility was up. He
took the league to court. The high court struck down the rule in 1971.
The decision became known as the "hardship rule," and under that rule
players can become eligible for the NBA draft�regardless of college or
high school standing.
Thirty years later, Mr. Haywood fears the rule has been
abused and isn�t necessarily good for players. On average, an NBA career
lasts a few years and with an influx of foreign players, the total
number of already scarce pro slots will dwindle lower, he said.
At the same time, more high schoolers and college
players are going hardship, whether their families actually need the
money or not.
"Now you have high school players looking at the NBA as
some sort of panacea. That�s taking away from the education aspect of a
high school student," Mr. Haywood argues. "A student is supposed to try
and accumulate as much education as they can. You must have some
intellect," he said, speaking May 16 in Chicago to promote the
August 4-5 "Spencer Haywood Who�s Who Hall of Fame Dinner" and "Shoot
The Hoop Reboot Celebrity Basketball Game." Organizers say some proceeds
from weekend events will go toward helping charter schools purchase
computers and text books.
NBA Commissioner David Stern would prefer not having any
players in the league who are younger than 20. But the NBA players�
union would have to agree to change their bargaining agreement. Union
head Billy Hunter told The Final Call, the union isn�t ready to
talk about it. Some sports agents threaten court battles if the NBA
seeks age restrictions, which would impact their pool of potential big
money contract talent. In this year�s upcoming NBA draft will be some 48
college underclassmen and high school players.
"Many athletes in his or her 20s are not equipped to
handle the celebrity status and big money contracts�and for most
teenagers it is an impossible task," warns Dr. Carole Lieberman, a
psychiatrist in Beverly Hills, Calif. "We agree in our field that the
biggest adjustment from high school to pro ball is the mental and
emotional rather than the physical."
"Very young NBA players have special needs, particularly
in the area of maturing as individuals. As long as that�s recognized and
provided for�there is no reason why highly skilled high schoolers can�t
succeed in the NBA," counters Tom "Satch" Sanders, a former Boston
Celtic who works as a league consultant.
The debate is a mix of arguments about money, player
exploitation, morality, education and opportunity.
Once Spencer Haywood went pro, Moses Malone from
Petersburg, Va., skipped college and joined the ABA in 1974. He signed
for $300,000 over 10 years. He later starred with the NBA Philadelphia
76ers, winning a championship.
In 1974, Bill Willoughby and Darryl Dawkins skipped
college for the pros. Mr. Dawkins, known as "Chocolate Thunder,"
possessed a gift for backboard shattering dunks and had success. Mr.
Willoughby lasted some years in the pros, but had injuries and never
quite lived up to his original billing.
It was 20 years later, in 1995, that another baby baller
entered the NBA: Kevin Garnett signed with Minnesota, then Kobe Bryant
and Jermaine O�Neal entered the league in 1996, followed by Tracy
McGrady. There have been 14 high schoolers drafted since Mr. Garnett.
The draft debate reached the boiling point around 1997,
when sports writers around the country repeated college official
complaints the NBA was stealing talent. Commissioner Stern shot back,
"Look at tennis, golf, baseball and other sports, and nobody talks about
their players� ages. Only for the NBA and NFL does it seem to be an
issue."
Talk also turned to how the NCAA made millions off of
"amateur" athletes, as the athletes struggled. One media account
described how pro star Chris Webber, while playing for the University of
Michigan couldn�t afford lunch at McDonald�s, but watched jerseys with
his name and number sell for $90 in the campus store. Previous sports
scandals have ushered in an era where athletes are denied many overt
perks and face restrictions on part-time work and gifts.
The exploitation expos�s helped fuel a mass exodus of
young college players into the NBA, led by Allen Iverson and Stephon
Marbury, according to observers.
Besides the money made by schools, there is also the
money needed by athletes� families.
"In many cases the responsibility of bringing economic
stability to one�s immediate family becomes a large burden to bear," Dr.
Lieberman said.
"If a kid truly has the ability to go out and make a lot
of money, you can�t hold them back," said DePaul University associate
head coach Tracy Dildy. "I personally believe you go to college to
position yourself to make a lot of money when you leave there. So if
they can find a quicker way to do that and it�s legal, I really can�t
cry foul."
He points to how tennis, golf and figure skating have
had very young athletes raking in big money. But Mr. Dildy is concerned
about how it applies to basketball, fearing players aren�t developing
their games by forgoing college.
"The typical student athletes of today differ
substantially from their predecessors, they usually arrive on campus
with lower academic qualifications," commented Bob Williams, founder of
the Bronx, N.Y.-based Sports Foundation. "What we find is that the
parents play an extremely important role, they know what their child can
handle," he added.
And with the family often needing money, community
organizations like the Sports Foundation can�t mount any successful
public campaign against drafting high school ballers, he said.
"I do not believe that these young people should be
drafted, they need college, they need to get all that higher education
has to offer," states Tommy Konchalski, a New Yorker who rates prep
basketball talent for publications like Street and Smith.
"Remember that when Kevin Garnett signed with Minnesota
he said that he would have gone to Michigan, if he had qualified
academically. Mr. Garnett was not patient enough to go the junior
college route to improve his grades," he added.
Kevin Garnett, an NBA All-Star with the Minnesota
Timberwolves, is the picture of the successful high school to pro
transition. Leon Smith, out of Chicago�s King High School, may be just
the opposite.
Drafted in the first round by the San Antonio Spurs in
1999 and traded to the Dallas Mavericks, he was reportedly urged to
spend a season oversees or in a developmental league. He reportedly
refused. Soon afterward, he was placed on injured reserve with a back
problem. During that period, the young man tried to commit suicide by
taking 200 aspirins. He was distraught over a failed relationship. He
had also been raised in a series of group and foster homes.
In February 2000, Leon Smith became a free agent. New
legal problems spawned 18 months probation imposed by a Cook County
Circuit Court judge for a misdemeanor charge of criminal damage to
property.
"Things like this have to be taken into account. Most
teenagers are still capable of doing child-like things. It is important
that they have time to mature�the NBA is not the place to grow up," Dr.
Lieberman insists.
The NBA commissioner is considering an eight-team
developmental league to begin in November 2001. It would play a 56-game
schedule, and be limited to players age 20 or older. Exceptions will be
made for high schoolers drafted by NBA teams and cut.
Mr. Haywood believes the developmental league will only
make matters worse. Paying players less in the new league and giving
them a non-college option will only help the NBA, he said.
What�s needed is to redirect the focus back to education
and preparedness for life, Mr. Haywood said.