A
fight for fairness
Corporate America still struggles with race, job bias
|
NEW YORK�Over the last decade the names of major
companies sued for racial discrimination reads like a "Who�s
Who" of American business: Texaco in 1996, settlement $176 million;
Shoney�s in 1993, a $132 million settlement; Winn-Dixie Stores in 1999,
settlement $33 million. In early January, Microsoft�s name surfaced as
attorneys sought class action status for a $5 billion racial bias lawsuit
against the computer software giant.
Recently analysts are asking, does the rash of lawsuits
create a disincentive for hiring women and minorities? Some critics claim
the lawsuits could make firms more leery of hiring Blacks. They cite the
rise in companies applying for employment insurance that provides up to
$50 million in coverage for compensatory damages, settlements, legal fees
and related costs.
Proponents of racial bias lawsuits say some employers
who have been sued continue to increase "minority hires" years
after settling discrimination claims. Shoney officials say the number of
"minority" managers at the company grew from 14.5 percent in
1993 to 38.9 percent in 2000.
Whether that is true or not, says Catalyst, a New
York-based research advisory group, the problem of discrimination has not
gone away. "Minority women are more than twice as likely as white
women to say there�s been no change in advancement opportunities in the
past five years," the research group found in a 1999 study.
National Urban League President Hugh Price told The
Final Call that as corporations move increasingly towards diversity
they will have to learn to treat all people with dignity. He and others
argue that as America�s racial make-up changes, companies must embrace
fair hiring not only because it is the right thing to do, but also because
it is good business.
"There are going to be lawsuits until the rules of
the game are straightened out and the playing field is leveled,"
predicts Mr. Price.
When asked if Blacks and Latinos will back away from
corporate America because of racism, he said they shouldn�t and can�t
afford to. "We have to keep pushing forward and send waves and waves
of our people at the barricades of opportunity," Mr. Price said.
There are apparently still some hurdles to equal
opportunity. Racial bias charges filed with the Equal Employment
Opportunity Commission jumped from 10,000 in the 1980s to nearly 50,000 in
the 1990s.
But that fact did not deter the many Black
professionals who attended the Rainbow/ Push Coalition�s Wall Street
Project 4th Annual Conference in New York City Jan. 23-26.
The meeting itself could be metaphor for striking an
uneasy balance: It is a showcase for companies looking to tout their
commitment to diversity, or can help shore up the image of firms with
problems. At the same time, it exposes business sectors where racial
barriers still exist. Using both a carrot and a stick that, hopefully,
yields change for Black businesses, suppliers and personnel, say its
supporters.
Many of the conference attendees told The Final Call
they came for a chance to grab a brass ring on their career carousel. They
were leery of being too critical of major corporations.
A young Black man from Santa Fe, Calif., spoke to The
Final Call on condition of anonymity. He had come to get help finding
a job with a Silicon Valley technology company. "It�s okay to go to
work for a Cisco (a major technology firm) and work up the ranks, enabling
you to bring in people of your ethnicity to that job so that they too can
become managers and CEOs," he said.
Others echoed the young man�s sentiments, saying that
they don�t plan to step back from working in corporate America.
"Where else is there to go?" they asked. But they also feel
corporations should accept workers from different racial and ethnic
backgrounds. In fact, nearly two-thirds of college students in a poll said
they believe it is important to work for an organization that values
diversity.
That data came from a survey of approximately 800
college and university students from around the world conducted at an
annual International Intern Leadership Conference held in 2000.
The Wall St. Project participants did not say corporate
racism was not a problem. They did say fear or a record of racial problems
would not stop them from seeking jobs.
There isn�t any need for workers to stay away from
companies that have been sued for bias, argues Suzanne Lasky, manager of
Customer Fulfillment at PRISM International, located in Orlando, Fla. The
company does strategic consulting, assessments, training and evaluates how
businesses cope with the racial mix in their workforces.
"I find that companies that we work with, Texaco,
Master Card International, IBM and Dennys, are not backing away from their
commitment to diversity," she said, adding, "These corporations
are continuing to invest in programs that will increase their
understanding of the diverse workforces they employ. We see nothing on the
horizon that this will change."
A few ardent defenders of corporations even call
discrimination a rare incident. But with figures showing Blacks on average
earn 78 percent of the wages of white counterparts; the unemployment rate
typically double for Blacks when compared to whites; and white men holding
most of the highest level positions, race is a stark reality in the
workplace.
"There�s nothing you can really do to explain to
the critics the vicious hate and pain of racism. They must don the skin of
a Black man or woman and deal with the slights�some overt�that rob you
of your spirit and will to compete," George Eddings of Houston, who
was involved in the class action suit against Coca-Cola, told reporters
last year. Coca-Cola, a major Wall St. Project sponsor, settled a major
job bias case in November for almost $200 million.
|