Clinton high, lows with Black community:
Lessons for future political elections, power?
by J.C. Palmer, Askia
Muhammad
and Jehron Muhammad |
WASHINGTON�In his final State of the Union
address, President Clinton called for an increase in funding for many
programs, including Head Start, more youth programs to prevent violence,
a $1 minimum wage increase, help for low and middle-income families to
pay college tuition, health care reform, and hiring new teachers and
more police officers.
For 89-minutes, the president spoke Jan. 26 to both
houses of Congress, perhaps the final time, saying Americans are
"fortunate to be alive at this moment in history."
But as the Clinton years are assessed, and Y2K
presidential elections inch closer, are there lessons to be learned from
how Black America dealt with Mr. Clinton and can they be applied to
those seeking the White House?
"While it is true that he brought more Blacks
into his administration than any other president, more Black men also
went to prison than ever before and more Blacks were executed under
capital punishment," observed Dr. Bart McSwine, chairman of the
African American Studies program at Chicago State University, who called
the Clinton presidency a mixed bag.
Dr. McSwine says the next president must do a better
job in addressing the "digital divide," the gap between access
to computers and technology between non-white students and their
Caucasian counterparts. Under Mr. Clinton, the problem worsened, and
Blacks have suffered the most because of it.
"This will effect the African American community�s
ability to become economically viable. For example, in the next 10
years, there will be a dramatic increase in the number of home
businesses. People without computers and access to the Internet cannot
start and maintain a successful home businesses," he said,
questioning the agenda behind hiring more teachers. Mr. Clinton said he
would like to hire additional 100,000 teachers for the nation�s
schools.
"I don�t see any emphasis on recruiting
minority teachers to offset the increasing enrollment of Blacks in
majority schools. The number of minority teachers has gone down while
the number of minority students has risen. As a result, most Black
students are now being taught by white teachers," he noted.
Dr. McSwine offers economics and education as
election issues for Blacks and favors curriculum reform to root Black
students in their "historical culture" and show them how to
thrive in modern society. "Under Clinton, the number of hate groups
has increased. African-centered education will introduce many to the
culture and eliminate the ignorance surrounding Africans and African
Americans," Dr. McSwine said.
"We have a problem as Black people because we
have taken from the Clinton administration whatever we were given in
terms of cabinet appointments and some policy. But we have not yet
driven a hard enough bargain with respect to making use of the leverage
we have as a significant minority within the Democratic Party,"
according to Dr. Ronald Walters, a University of Maryland political
science professor.
"We have traded loyalty for leverage. That puts
us in a position of taking the least of what we could get. I think that
lesson is still on the table, which is to say, that even where we have a
president who appears to like us, and who wants to give us symbolic
public policy victories, we ought to reject those in favor of using the
maximum leverage against that administration to extract the public
policy our people need. That is what we need to do with (Vice President
Al) Gore, and that is what we have not done yet with the Clinton
administration," he said.
Barbara Arnwine, executive director of the Lawyers
Committee for Civil Rights, agrees. "No matter how friendly an
administration is, you have to really hold them accountable," she
said, adding that the Clinton administration did some good, but had
stumbles "disastrous for Black people."
The Lani Guinier debacle, rectified by appointment of
Deval Patrick as assistant Attorney General for Civil Rights, was a
terrible fight and the White House dropped the ball in California, where
affirmative action opponents won major victories. The administration is
on the wrong side of Gov. Jeb Bush�s "One Florida"
anti-affirmative action plan, she added.
"Unfortunately, I think that a lot of the mark
of the Clinton administration is going to be gone quickly because they
did not take steps to make their policy changes lasting. If in fact a
Republican administration came in, you would see a quick turnover of all
those policies, because of a failure to do a lot of the
groundwork," Ms. Arnwine said.
Hugh Price, president of the New York-based National
Urban League, feels Mr. Clinton�s talk of tax cuts for working people
and poor people, higher minimum wage, and helping families afford higher
education sounds good.
Mr. Clinton�s record number of appointments of
Blacks and people of color�among them Franklin Raines, head of the
Office of Management and Budget, Transportation Secretary Rodney Slater,
Labor Secretary Alexis Herman�helped advance interests of those
groups, said Mr. Price. With "the general rebirth of the American
economy, we�ve seen the vital signs of the African American community
are stronger than they�ve been in recent memory because our
unemployment rate overall is at record lows, and our teenage
unemployment is at record lows," he noted. Though youth
unemployment is still too high, the Black middle class has grown and
emphasis on improving public education is correct, said Mr. Price.
In Mr. Price�s view, presidential candidates should
be pressed to make "serious commitments" to better urban
schools, rural schools, pre-schools and qualified teachers, an
investment that pays off later in life.
He gave Mr. Clinton an "incomplete" on the
White House race initiative.
Discrimination in lending, access to capital for
business, home and mortgage loans persist, and police brutality has to
be brought under control and Africa faces challenges with AIDS, and
foreign debt�other areas for presidential vote seekers to address.
Thad Mathis, a professor of Social Administration and
associate dean at Temple University, noted the speech lacked talk of the
people who lost entry-level and low wage jobs in the high-tech,
high-skill level jobs created by the economy and talk of the fate of
those on welfare. Many former welfare recipients bounce from temporary
job to temporary job, Mr. Mathis said. "They�re just going
someplace to get a check instead of going to the welfare office. But
they aren�t in better economic circumstances as a result of these
changes. In fact some of them may get less benefits than they had
before."
Calling most Clinton contributions symbolic, Mr.
Mathis gave him credit for the race initiative historian John Hope
Franklin chaired, opposition to flying the Confederate flag, the apology
for the Tuskegee syphilis experiment, and speaking out on the right side
of major race issues�even if he didn�t aggressively do much on the
issues. If anyone benefited during Mr. Clinton�s tenure, it was middle
class Blacks, whose access to power was expanded, he said.
Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) members have gripes
with Mr. Clinton on welfare reform, the death penalty, mandatory minimum
jail sentencing guidelines, the lack of financial aid to sub-Sahara
Africa, among other issues.
CBC Chair James Clyburn of South Carolina admits that
despite some "kicking and screaming" by administration
officials: "The White House has been very, very good. We don�t
think it�s been all that we�ve wanted, but when you compare what the
legislative response has been to so many of our initiatives, and what we
were able to do when we were able to get the White House to veto the
budget; those kinds of things lead us to feel that this president�s
initiatives have been the basis for us to build a launching pad."
"We are going to ask the president to make some
�in your face� appointments," continued Rep. Clyburn. "We�re
going to put judicial appointments out here in the presidential
campaign. We�re going to put affirmative action into the presidential
campaign.
"We�re going to put mandatory sentencing into
the presidential campaign. We�re going to put the restoration of
voting rights for felons into the presidential campaign. We�re going
to talk about a woman�s right to choose and whether or not we�ll
have three Supreme Court justices appointed by the next president."
One of the first tests of the CBC direct action
agenda will take place on March 7, according to Rep. Corrine Brown (D-Fla.),
who is planning a massive march in support of affirmative action at the
Florida state capitol in Tallahassee. |