(Finalcall.com)�Blacks are shelling out more green for major financial
services, according to new data that shows skin color matters more than
the color of money.
Evidence of raced-based pricing exists in life, home and auto
insurance, auto purchasing and bank lending. Language shifts, members of
these industries say, only cover the reality that Blacks are paying
more. While national efforts have developed to create fairer rates and
policies, financial experts say consumer education is the key to
stopping systematic rip-offs.
Although pricing life insurance solely on race was outlawed by the
early 1970s, insurance executives recently revealed that Black people
are still paying higher premiums on policies taken out decades ago.
"The companies did not go back and upgrade the policy of the Black
policyholder to the same face amount of the white policyholder," said
Bill Goodman, special litigation counsel for the Texas Department of
Insurance. As a result, Blacks have continued to pay more for less
benefits based on these old racial double standards.
Mr. Goodman is a part of a national task force that was organized
after these practices were made public. The National Association of
Insurance Commissioners have been examining the books of insurance
companies and have identified 76 that are still collecting premiums with
rates established based on race.
Referring to figures listed in the 1960 Little Gem Life Chart, an
independently published analysis of life insurance, Mr. Goodman noted
the differences in death benefits for a policy taken out at birth: $357
for a white child and $277 for a Black child.
After it became illegal to categorize policies by race, "standard"
replaced "white" and "premium" replaced "Black" or "Colored" and
"hazardous occupation" was another way to rate Black people�s policies
higher, he added.
Today, the language revolves around credit history, according to
insurance professionals. Some officers claim that credit is a useful
tool, pointing to data showing the relationship between credit ratings
and risks on insurance on life, home and auto. Others, however, laugh at
the concept that someone�s credit rating has anything to do with the
possibility that their house will catch on fire.
"I am especially concerned about credit in this context since credit
was used as a pretext 20-30 years ago for race-based pricing," said Mr.
Goodman, "I am very, very, very, very, very suspicious."
Hank Schwaab, a Black man who worked in the insurance industry for
over 60 years, also believes credit scoring is racially biased. "When we
write a homeowner�s policy or automobile policy, then we must also
submit a financial report showing that these people who have applied for
insurance have a clean record, not having bounced any checks," he said.
"I feel that this is discrimination," Mr. Scwaab continued, "because
obviously people in wealthy neighborhoods do not bounce checks as a
rule, whereas other people in poorer neighborhoods who live from payday
to payday sometimes can�t help themselves and they get in trouble. They
pay higher rates for insurance."
Insurance rates based on zip codes have also been widely criticized
by some insurance professionals. Defenders of this practice say an
area�s crime and population density contribute to a higher rate of
accidents; critics say the method is misused to target inner cities.
Consumers face even greater challenges when buying cars. Interest
rate mark-ups determined by dealers generate profits that are split
between dealers and lenders. Rarely is the customer aware of the
percentage point increase, which is based partly on their credit
history.
According to a study conducted by Vanderbilt professor Mark A. Cohen,
Nissan gained more than $210 million in revenue since 1990 based on
dealer mark-ups of Black consumers. Blacks received mark-ups twice as
many times as whites, 72.8 percent of Black car buyers versus 46.7
percent of white consumers, according to a July 4 New York Times report
on the study. The largest mark-up gap was found in Wisconsin, with
Blacks paying an additional $1132 versus a $301 average mark-up for
whites.
In the same article, a study of Nissan by Yale Law Professor Ian
Ayres indicated lenders set limits on mark-ups for consumers with top
quality credit, who were mostly whites. Greater mark-ups were allowed on
loans with longer terms, which are taken out mostly by Blacks. In the
study, Professor Ayres noted: "None of these selective mark-up caps are
justified by the dealerships� costs of arranging and or processing loan
applications."
The discovery of such arbitrary practices set forth a series of class
action suits against insurance companies and car dealerships across the
nation. Nat Shapo, director of the Illinois Department of Insurance,
also a member of the national insurance task force, said state
commissioners have signed a resolution agreeing to seek a national
resolution of settlements to victimized customers. Because there is no
federal regulation of insurance, state laws vary regarding insurance
practices, posing a serious challenge for the task force.
For the consumer, "education is the beginning," said Diane Ashley of
Citigroup, stressing the need to look at loan interest rates,
particularly mortgage loans. "One of the biggest, easiest flags to note
is prepayment penalties. The companies that are on the up and up are not
going to charge or penalize you if you wanted to pay it off earlier,"
she noted.
Other issues involve default policies and additional things they make
you purchase along with the loan, she said. "Do they require you to buy
single premium credit life insurance, which is a big scam because they
get a lot of profit out of that," she said.
"Black people have been paying more since eternity," commented Mickey
Bowers, president of a Ford dealership in Randallstown, Maryland. Black
people should patronize Black dealerships because the dealers will have
the customers� best interest in mind, he said. Mr. Bowers said his
customers are shown their interest rate alongside the rate that the
banks charge his dealership, assuring customers they are not getting
ripped off.
Consumers can also gain financial literacy on their own through
competitive shopping and research, said numerous insurance executives.
"When you are knowledgeable, you�re likely to get fairer rates," Rev.
Jesse Jackson told The Final Call during the 30th annual Rainbow/Push
Coalition Convention. "Ignorant people get exploited. That�s why
knowledge is power."
Rainbow/Push sponsored several workshops on financial issues, hosted
by industry professionals during their convention titled, "One Big Tent:
Pursuing the American Dream."
Ending this "economic bloodsucking" is key in getting economic
justice, the "Fourth Movement in the Freedom Symphony" which began with
abolishing slavery, ending segregation and gaining the right to vote,
said Rev. Jackson. During the convention, he outlined strategies to
eliminate "patterns of predatory economic race profiling," noting that
the need for reparations for segregation is more documented than it is
for slavery. Raced-based financial services, he said, "is a function of
colonialism that is profoundly deep and very exploitative."