NEW YORK�Whether
the government knew, or how much it knew, about the impending Sept. 11,
2001 attack on the World Trade Center is weighing heavy on family
members of victims, even as New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg prepares to
officially end recovery efforts at the site.
To date, the New
York City medical examiner says that some 19,000 body parts have been
recovered from the 16-acre site where once stood the twin towers of the
World Trade Center. New York City officials say that all human remains
should be removed from Ground Zero by June.
On May 1 this
year, a young bride of three years appeared on a local television news
program to explain how happy she was to receive four identifiable body
parts belonging to her husband�the last article sent was his heart. Her
husband was one of the 2,552 victims at work on �9/11� that did not make
it out.
She was a junior
high school teacher on September 11. Shortly after the attacks, she left
her job to become an advocate for families of victims. Many New Yorkers
share her passion when it comes to the fallen 110-foot twin towers and
the loss of their loved ones.
Why talk about
body parts?
Well, for many
families that is all they have � except for the memories. This is the
story of September 11 at �Ground Zero� as told through Blacks who
experienced the horror or family members of victims. In the moments
after the first plane struck the north tower, chaos filled the streets.
When the first tower collapsed, the faces of people were covered in
dirt, soot, bewilderment, grief and horror. You could not tell White
from Black as they trudged across the Brooklyn Bridge out of harm�s way.
�
At 9:10 a.m.,
Kenneth Cubas, 48, called his mother on Staten Island and reassured her
that he was fine. He worked on the 97th
floor in Tower Two as a computer engineer for Fiduciary Trust.
Moments earlier, at 9:05 a.m., United Airlines Flight 175, a Boeing 767
jet had slammed into his building, creating a red ball of fire that lit
up the New York skyline. There were 2,000 people in the building at that
time; 600 of them did not make it.
�He told me, �I�m
okay, ma, see you tonight,� � says Dorothy Cubas, 76, remembering her
last conversation with her son. �He told me to turn on the television
and I would see the fire in his building, but he reassured me that he
was fine.
�The 21 years that
Kenneth was married, he would call me at least once every week. I miss
his phone calls,� she says sadly.
Kenneth, separated
from his wife, lived with his mother for three years. Ms. Cubas
remembers her son trying to be quiet in the mornings as he prepared for
work so as not to wake her, but he would always say good-bye when he was
leaving. He moved into his own apartment in April 2001, so, on the
morning of Sept. 11, there was no �see you tonight, ma.�
�I guess that is
why he called me. He knew I would be expecting to hear from him,� she
says. �I saw what was happening on my television. I put it in God�s
hands, and for a while, I expected to see him walk through my front
door, just like he promised.�
Ms. Cubas
remembers her son as a loving person who bent over backwards to help
others. Kenneth�s brother Larry, 50, fondly remembers how Kenneth was
the peacemaker between he and another brother, Alfonso, 47.
�I remember as we
were growing up, he would fight with me to make me tough, but if anyone
else bothered me, he would speak up for me,� Larry says.
Larry Cubas works
two blocks away from the WTC area as a foreign exchange trader, but on
Sept. 11, he was in London on business. �Eight months after the attacks,
I still think about my brother every day, and I am still trying to make
some sense of his death,� he says. �I think about the way the buildings
came down and how the plane crashed on the floors below my brother and I
try to imagine his last minutes.�
Kenneth Cubas was
one of 128 Black men killed in the attack. The largest ethnic group
victimized were White males, 1, 593, according to the NYC Department of
Health. There were 79 Black women killed, 394 White women, 166 Hispanic
males, 87 Hispanic women, 112
Asian & Pacific
Island men and 53 Asian & Pacific Island women. Most of the victims were
between 30 to 44 years of age.
�
�I opened the door
of our home and my wife is sitting in the living room crying and I sit
down and cry with her,� admits Ben Glascoe, 64, public affairs director
for Con Edison. He has been married to his wife Gloria for 40 years and
had two children, Keith Alexander Glascoe, 38, and a married daughter,
Lee Wright, 37.
Keith was a NYC
fireman, one of the 343 that died at the WTC. Twelve of the 343 were
Black; another twelve were Latino.
Mr. Glascoe
describes his son as a handsome young man that modeled and had movie and
television credits under his belt. �He appeared in the 1991 movie The
Professional, and he appeared on soap operas such as The Guiding
Light,� Mr. Glascoe says proudly, adding that his son became a
fireman because he wanted a regular check with good benefits.
�Keith has two
sons, one is three, the other is a year-and-a-half, and my son wanted to
make sure they were taken care of,� Mr. Glascoe says.
When the
three-year-old visits, the first thing he does is take out the funeral
palm cards from his dad�s memorial service and lays them out carefully,
Mr. Glascoe explains.
�He puts the cards
away, looks at me, and asks me when is his daddy coming home. It breaks
my heart to look into his little face,� says Mr. Glascoe. He pauses
several times during the interview, fighting back tears. �We miss our
son so much,� he says.
The uniform
services, fire, police and emergency medical technicians have received
most of the public accolades for what they did on Sept. 11. A photo of
Keith Alexander Glascoe hangs in front of the Vulcan Hall, home of the
Black fireman�s association. He was not a member of the Vulcans, but
they honor him just the same.
The ranks of Black
NYC firefighters are too small to ignore a fireman that lost his life
simply because he did not join the Vulcan Society, Vulcan President Lt.
Paul Washington explained to The Final Call. Of the 11,500 NYC
fire personnel, less than four percent are Black.
Captain Paul
Green, 62, served as a fireman for 35 years and knew most of the 343
firefighters killed. But, because there are so few Black firefighters
losing just one is critical, he says.
�Most of the guys
we lost on September 11 were young, such as Keith Maynard,� Capt. Green
adds. �Young Maynard was an up and coming firefighter who came to the
Vulcan Society and jumped in with both feet. There was also Vernon
Cherry and Leon Smith who come to mind as guys I miss seeing at our
meetings.�
In a more
reflective tone, he talks about a day in 1966 when he lost 12
firefighters in a fire on 23rd Street in Manhattan: �I thought that was
my most depressing day, but that was a picnic compared to September 11.�
Fireman Keith
Maynard, 30, was the sergeant-at-arms for the Vulcan Society. �I still
feel my brother�s spirit,� says older brother Vernon Maynard. �Since
September 11, there has been an empty space in my heart.�
Mr. Maynard said
his brother always wanted to be a fireman.
�I remember Keith
was six-years-old and a fire engine passed as we walked with our mother,
he shouted at the top of his lungs, �I want to be a fireman,� and he
died doing what he loved to do,� Mr. Maynard says. �My brother was full
of life, he loved his job and he was dedicated to the job.�
Lieutenant Ella
McNair, 44, the first Black woman to achieve that rank in NYC, says that
losing all the men was traumatic for her. Victim Capt. Vernon Richards
was her mentor.
�He took me under
his wing and helped me with the lieutenant�s test,� she says. �He taught
me how to fight to keep the job that I love so much. It is hard to
understand what those guys went through, dying the way they did.�
Lt. McNair
received her rank in January 2002. �I earned my stripes. They did not
give them to me; I earned them,� she says defiantly.
Only the body of
one Black fireman has been recovered and the jacket of another was
found, according to Lt. Washington.
�
The Port Authority
Police lost 37 officers and 38 civilian workers on 9/11. Nine of the
officers�Donald Foreman, Walter McNeil, Nathaniel Webb, Bruce Reynolds,
David LaMast, Clinton Davis, Walwyn Stewart, Uhuru Houston and James
Parham�were Black. According to the Port Authority Director of Public
Information Alan Hicks, many of the civilian workers were Black and
Latino.
However, if the
full story about the Black experience of 9/11 is to be known, Port
Authority Police Capt. Anthony Richard Whitaker, 57, can tell it. �I am
still the commander here,� he told The Final Call from his office
at the Holland Tunnel. He has been available at �Ground Zero� on a
12-hour on, 12-hour off basis. When asked to reflect on the reaction he
had on Sept. 12, after having a better chance to evaluate the condition
of the complex, he says, �I cried.�
�I had been
transferred for a while to 1 Police Plaza, to man the phones, and I was
crying then,� he says. �I still cry today, eight months later and I
don�t know why.�
Speaking of the
twin towers, he said, �Those two towers had character. They had energy
and a sense of mystery.�
There were seven
buildings located at the 16-acre complex and Capt. Whitaker says he knew
every inch of each building. He knew thousands of the people that worked
there, because for the 28-months he was in charge, he would greet them
down in the shopping mall area as they left the various modes of
transportation into the complex.
�I call it
community policing. Four days of the week, I stood in front of [the
Banana Republic] store greeting the commuters coming off the P.A.T.H.
train and going to work,� he says.
When the attack
hit, �We quickly evacuated the mall area. There were 78 stores and
miraculously we got everyone out,� he recalls.
One thing Capt.
Whitaker observed that morning was that many of the people he was used
to seeing were missing. �I said to myself, this is not the normal number
of folks we have coming through on a Tuesday morning. I later learned
that was Election Day in New York City,� he says with a curious tone in
his voice.
September 11, 2001
was the scheduled day for the long expected mayoral primary. The voting
was later suspended by then-Mayor Rudolph Guiliani.
Capt. Whitaker�s
story continues with him proceeding to the lobby of the north tower.
�I am standing in
the lobby, and there is complete silence, but that did not last for long
because in a few minutes I hear a roaring sound like thunder coming in
my direction,� he recalls.
He said the roar
was a huge ball of fire coming down the corridor. �There are people
running in front of the ball of fire, there are people caught in the
ball of fire, and there are people being thrown from the ball, and all
of that is headed straight for me,� he continues. That is when the
captain says things became fuzzy.
�I thought that I
had dove into a doorway as the ball passed me by, but a security guard
that is always stationed there said I scooped him up as the fire ball
was approaching and we dove into a closet. Here this guy is thanking me
for saving his life and I do not remember a thing.
�Not just the
security guard, I am told that I saved the lives of 25 PA police
officers,� he says. �All I remember of those few minutes was getting
away from the ball of fire and after that, seeing two people running
towards me completely consumed in flames, and they ran past me never
saying a word.
�At that point I
remember giving the order on my radio to completely evacuate the
complex,� he says. �As I am running from the lobby a voice tells me not
to look down. I hear this weird sound under my feet and if I had looked
down, I would have known that I was stepping on bodies and body parts.
Outside the buildings we kept hearing the sound of explosives, that
sound was made by people crashing to the ground,� he says, his voice
growing softer as he remembers the events.
By then, he had
made it to the street, and that is when plane number two hit. �I
remember giving the order to evacuate for the second time,� he says. �I
remember giving orders to three Black officers�Walter McNeil, David
Foreman and Bruce Reynolds�to stay at the command desk and establish
land-line communications with our command in Jersey City, New Jersey. I
remember sending Officer Nathaniel Webb with a New York City fire chief,
and the look that Officer Webb gave me. We made eye contact until he was
out of sight. He was saying with his eyes, �why me, why do I have to
go,� � Capt. Whitaker recalls painfully.
When asked if he
regrets giving those last orders, he said, �No!�
�I walked around
in a daze for six months. Oh, I functioned, but it was like I was having
a daily out-of-body experience,� he says.
�
One person who
cannot talk about September 11 is Bobby Griffin. His wife of seven
years, Tawanna, 30, worked as a cashier for Forte Foods on the 101st
floor of the south tower. Forte Foods catered to the workers for the
securities firm Cantor Fitzgerald.
Her sister-in-law,
Juanita Inniss, recalls Ms. Griffin�s story.
�September was
supposed to be a happy month for my brother and his wife,� she says.
Tawanna�s birthday had just passed on Sept. 4 and the couple celebrated
their seventh wedding anniversary on Sept. 2. They have one child, Bobby
Jr., age five.
Ms. Inniss says
that her brother watched what unfolded at the WTC from his home in
Brooklyn. �I called him after I heard what had happened, he said he felt
helpless, he wanted to reach out to his wife,� Ms. Inniss says. �Even
then he could not cry.�
She told The
Final Call that from the beginning she was trying to make some sense
out of what was happening. �All I could think of was Tawanna and how
much she loved Bobby Jr. Until the buildings collapsed, I had hope that
she would be fine,� Ms. Inniss recalls.
She said that over
200 people showed up at the memorial service, even though Ms. Griffin�s
body was not recovered. �My mother is the only one able to talk freely
about what happened. Little Bobby tells everyone that his mother is up
in heaven,� she says.
Ms. Inniss says
that what bothers her most is that no one talks about the loss of the
regular people like Tawanna Griffin. �She did not wear a uniform, but
she was there and she lost her life. Isn�t that important?� she asks.
�
There were
thousands of unsung heroes that day. One of them was Darryl Taylor, 52,
who worked as an office manager on the 83rd floor in the north tower. He
was not able to communicate with his family, but he did contact his
company in New Jersey by fax.
�The telephones
were knocked out immediately, but Darryl used his head and stayed in
touch with the company,� Greg Taylor, his brother, said. What bothers
his family is that most of the people on the 83rd floor made it out, but
everyone working with Darryl Taylor died.
�We think that
something was wrong with the fire door,� says Gyasi El-Bey, another
brother. There are five children in the
Taylor
family. Their father Carl Taylor Sr., 78, lives in North Carolina. �We
talked with our father from the very first moment that we learned of the
attack,� the brothers explained. �He was very sad then and he is still
distraught,� they say.
�We can imagine
that Darryl, being one of the oldest persons at work, helped to keep
everyone calm, even as things turned ugly,� Greg Taylor says.
Darryl Taylor was
a fixture in the Black community on Staten Island. He played drums, both
acoustic and congas. Many people say he reached the lives of many people
through his cultural pursuits and through the quiet dynamism of his
personality.
Staten Island has
a population of 450,000, and on September 11, more than 200 people from
the Island lost their lives at the WTC, 78 of them firemen. The Black
community of
Staten Island, according to census figures, numbers around
30,000.
�Darryl was the
kind of guy that you knew had to be present when something was about to
happen,� remembers Tim Martin, a life-long friend. �It was like when he
entered the room, it became official.�
Mr. El-Bey and Mr.
Taylor say they hope to use any money from the federal September 11 Fund
for music scholarships for Black children on Staten Island. �We want to
memorialize Darryl in some special way,� they say. Darryl Taylor never
married and had no children of his own.
�It is good that
the family wants to establish the scholarship fund,� Sajdah Muserwere
Ladner told The Final Call. Ms. Ladner runs the Temple of The
Arts, a cultural program located on Staten Island. Darryl was an
important fixture in the cultural life of Black Staten Islanders, she
says.
�
Al Smith, 62,
never thought he would ever hear the word hero attached to his name, but
his exploits of Sept. 11 changed that forever. He said that his life is
returning to some sense of normalcy eight months after the attacks. But
he never tires of telling his story.
He worked as a
messenger for the Port Authority on the 68th floor. He actually worked
for a temporary agency, but the PA liked him so much they kept him on,
he says.
On Sept. 11, Mr.
Smith and five other men were stuck in an elevator somewhere around the
50th floor in the north tower. They dug their way out by cutting through
the firewall with a window washer�s squeegee.
�I was the
smallest, so I crawled out through the small opening we had made and
went for help. Ironically, I ran into a fireman who came back with me
and led all of us out of the building to safety,� Mr. Smith says.
He said he had
gone downstairs to get breakfast for Ms. Mary Jones, 71, a receptionist
in the PA office. �I would get breakfast every morning for Ms. Jones.
She was like a mother figure to all of us,� he says.
�I
never made it back with her breakfast, and I never saw her again. Miss
Mary had a bad hip and had trouble walking and had to be helped down the
stairs. They made it to the sixth floor and she became tired. They
turned her over to the firemen and before they could get out the
building �� he hesitates. �You know, when I think back on that day, I
can only thank God for keeping me alive,� he says.