Illinois
governor says stop executions
by Toure Muhammad |
CHICAGO�Anti-death row activists applauded
Republican Gov. Bill Ryan�s plan to stop the execution of Death Row
inmates, but warned that this first step must be a meaningful walk
towards the abolishment of the death penalty.
Responding to a chorus of activists, politicians and
religious leaders, the governor�s decision comes after 13 men were
exonerated in the past 13 years�including some who came within days
from being executed or served as much as 18 years in prison.
"There is no margin for error when it comes to
putting a person to death," said Gov. Ryan at a news conference
Jan. 31, where he called for the creation of a special panel to
investigate the state�s severely tainted capital punishment system.
The moratorium will remain, "until I can be sure that everyone
sentenced to death in Illinois is truly guilty," he said.
"If the governor is not going to deal with the
need for adequate legal council, then it is not doing Black and poor
people any good at all," said Nation of Islam Prison Minister
Abdullah Muhammad. "It will only delay the executions."
If the governor is sincere, he must "seek out
those law enforcement officials who have conducted official
misconduct," said the prison minister who made reference to death
row inmate Nathson Fields, whose trial was overseen by Judge Thomas J.
Maloney, who is now serving 15 years for taking a bribe in another death
row case. "Those judges, attorneys and police officers who take
bribes, torture people and commit other official acts of misconduct
should be severely punished.
"Ultimately, the death penalty should be
abolished all together," said Min. Abdullah, who stands with all
those who are calling for an abolishment of the death penalty on behalf
of the Honorable Minister Louis Farrakhan and the Nation of Islam.
"I don�t think that there can be true justice until God�s law
replaces man�s law. And God�s law can only be established by the
anointed of God and those working with him," he added.
Popular political radio talk show host Cliff Kelley
said the governor�s call was "meaningless, because he�s still
in favor of the death penalty." Mr. Kelley, who serves as vice
chairman of the American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois (ACLU),
suggested the governor�s moratorium may be a smoke screen to take
attention off the current licensing scandal that involves his former
State�s Attorney�s Office. "If he said he was against it (death
penalty), that would be meaningful."
Those who end up on death row have less to do with
justice and more with economics and race, critics charge.
According to the American Bar Association and
numerous scholars, "it is not the facts of the crime, but the
quality of legal representation, that distinguishes cases in which the
death penalty is imposed from similar cases in which it is not imposed.
And the overwhelming majority of people on death row received
substandard legal representation at trial, they say.
A recent survey conducted by the National Law Journal
found that over half of the death row inmates in six southern states had
been represented by lawyers who had never before handled a capital case.
The study concluded that capital trials are "more like a random
flip of a coin than a delicate balancing of the scales" because the
defense lawyer is too often "ill trained, unprepared and grossly
underpaid."
Bill Ryan of the Illinois Moratorium Project, State
Representative Coy Pugh and other long-time anti-death penalty activists
applauded the governor�s decision, including the ACLU of Illinois:
"We also are gratified that the Governor has taken this courageous
step at this time, so the death penalty issue is removed from the
legislative arena in an election year," said Jay Miller, executive
director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Illinois.
If the death penalty is stopped in Illinois, it would
be the first state to actually do so among states the reinstated the
death penalty since 1977. Since the death penalty was reinstated, 12
people have been put to death and 13 exonerated. |