911
tapes cast doubt on guilt of Muslim imam
The
controversial release of the March 16, 911 emergency tape and
dispatch record involving the shooting death of an Atlanta deputy
and the wounding of his partner has landed a contempt of court
charge against Fulton County Sheriff Jackie Barrett and added to a
month of controversy surrounding pending murder trial of Muslim
cleric Imam Jamil Abdullah Al-Amin, formerly known as H. Rap
Brown.
Superior Court Judge Stephanie B. Manis ruled
on May 31 that Sheriff Barrett violated a gag order that forbade
release of evidence in the case against Imam Al-Amin, who is
accused of murdering Deputy Ricky Kinchen and wounding his partner
Aldranon English, according to an Atlanta Journal-Constitution
article. Atlanta prosecutor Paul Howard announced in April that
the state�s intended to seek the death penalty.
In the ruling, Judge Manis said the sheriff did
not willfully intend to violate the order, and thus the contempt
was not criminal, and without punishment. Ms. Barrett testified
that the release occurred on the advice of a county attorney, and
focused strictly on compliance with open records law, reports
said.
Judge Manis also ruled that despite requests
from both defense and prosecution, she would send the imam�s
case back through the random pool for the selection of a superior
court judge. Mr. Al-Amin has yet to enter a plea although has
proclaimed innocence on the charges against him. His arraignment
on the 13-count indictment will not take place before a judge is
officially assigned to the case.
On May 17, FBI officials announced the arrest
of two men they believe are tied to three bank robberies in a
22-day period. One of the robbers alleges they robbed the banks
for the imam�s defense fund. However, according to a May 19
Atlanta Journal Constitution article, FBI supervisor Mark
Giuliano found no evidence that Imam Al-Amin benefited from the
robberies. According to the article, Ibrahim Abdul Salaam, a
member of the imam�s West End mosque, said efforts to raise
money for the imam�s defense had stopped, as taxpayers will now
pay his legal expenses.
Mr. Al-Amin�s lawyers are attempting to
exploit the 911 evidence released, as it raises the possibility of
another slay suspect. So far, the imam is the only one charged in
the shootings.
Dispatch excerpts reveal fellow deputies
searched for a wounded gunman and surrounded an abandoned building
where blood was found. The 1182 Oak Street building is five blocks
from Mr. Amin�s place of business where officers said they
attempted to serve the imam with a warrant. Deputy English said he
shot his assailant.
According to the 911 excerpts, minutes after
the shooting a man was seen bleeding and begging for a ride five
blocks from the shooting scene. On May 30, defense attorney Jack
Martin filed a motion seeking all police evidence concerning other
persons at the crime scene. An additional search for reports about
the blood and reports of anyone wounded in the West End area of
Atlanta the night of March 16 are also being sought.
After the shooting, one 911 caller reported an
injured man on Westview Avenue. "Caller advises perp in a
vacant building on Westview bleeding begging for a ride," a
dispatcher typed into the log of the shooting.
Police have not released further details about
the bleeding man or the 911 caller. |