PARIS�Increasingly, the Catholic Church is showing an
intolerance for the rise of Islam in Europe and the West,
traditional strongholds of Christianity, the chief imam of France
said in an exclusive interview.
"Islam has become the scapegoat of other religions,"
said Dr. Dalil Boubakeur, imam of the Muslim Institute of the
Mosque of Paris, the largest mosque in France. "There is no
territorial religion in Europe. If Islam has had success in
Europe, the Christians also have had success in China, India,
Africa."
Dr. Boubakeur�s remarks stemmed from questions The Final Call
posed about a recent attack on Islam made by Cardinal Paul Poupard,
the Vatican-based head of the Papal Cultural Council and a close
assistant to Pope John Paul II. In the hierarchy of the Roman
Catholic Church, cardinals rank just below the pope.
The cardinal headlined the Sept. 30 issue of Le Figaro, the
French national daily, in which he stated that the spread of Islam
in Europe represented a "serious problem" to Christians.
And while the cardinal was careful to distinguish between Islam
and "fundamental" Islam, he cautioned, nonetheless, that
this distinction "does not mean that Islam still does not
represent a fearsome challenge to Europe and the West, and, to
Christian hopes, a serious problem."
"To be conscious of this growing presence of Islam,
particularly in a Europe where the borders are more and more
porous, is to face a reality," Cardinal Poupard said.
"We must prepare ourselves and face this problem without
passion.
"It is not necessary to be a great expert to realize a
growing distortion between two demographic curves. In the
countries of Christian cultures, the demography is progressively
dropping; while we realize the inverse in the young Muslim
countries," the cardinal added.
The cardinal could not be reached at the Vatican in Rome. But a
secretary at the Vatican Embassy in Paris said that the majority
of Catholic clergy were away in Lourdes, France, attending a
weeklong plenary assembly of French bishops.
Dr. Boubakeur said he did not wish to meet with Cardinal
Poupard until the cardinal has issued an apology to the Muslim
community.
And although Le Figaro, a popular French newspaper, published
Dr. Boubakeur�s rebuttal a week later in its Oct. 7 issue, it
did so without the fanfare that was conferred upon the cardinal.
For Dr. Boubakeur, Christianity�s attack on Islam is a
historical one that goes back 904 years to the Crusades, a series
of wars fought by Western European Christians to recapture the
city of Jerusalem from Muslims.
"Europe�s colonization of Muslim countries has given a
complex of superiority to churches and people that the European
example is the best in the world," Dr. Boubakeur said.
"We fear that it is a racist attitude towards Arabs,
Africans, Islam, and Jews during the last war."
Islam in Europe
Muslims comprise less than 10 percent of Europe�s population,
Dr. Boubakeur said. But the rise of Islam here poses the threat of
a rival culture and religion, as Cardinal Poupard and others see
it.
"The challenge stems from the fact that Islam is supposed
to be religion, culture and society, a way of life, of thinking
and of behavior," Cardinal Poupard told Le Figaro. "The
actuality shows us that this Islam does not change. At the same
time in Europe, some Christians, under the pressure of society and
also interior ferments, wish for the marginalization of their
church in relation to society, accepting the �privatization�
of this church�a word that horrifies me. They will forget Lent,
judged �square,� but will be interested, if not fascinated, by
Ramadan (the Islamic month of fasting) ..."
Fundamentalist right-winger Jean-Marie Le Pen, president of the
National Front, was less eloquent.
"Islam is a religion of more than a billion men, young,
generally poor. For our materialistic and decadent world this is
an objective threat," Mr. Le Pen said in a speech given in
Paris last September.
A poll for Le Nouvel Observateur magazine in 1998 reported that
nearly 66 percent of the French thought that the country had
"too many Arabs" and "too many Muslims."
Clearly, Europe is a Christian continent. The majority of its
311 million inhabitants are adherents of the Trinitarian churches�Roman
Catholic, Protestant Episcopalian, Anglican�believers in the
doctrine of the Trinity.
Islam, on the other hand, adheres to the belief in the One God,
Allah. And God has no intercessor, Dr. Boubakeur said.
"But the Qur�an says leave each people in his own way.
No one is obliged to share my convictions," he added.
Muslims are still the minority in popular European countries.
France, for instance, is 90 percent Roman Catholic, 2 percent
Protestant, and about 5 percent Muslim. Great Britain is 60
percent Protestant Episcopal and Roman Catholic, followed by
Anglican, and 1 percent Muslim.
Nevertheless, European official-doms� interpretations of
these numbers reveal a collective fear of an Islamic conquest of
Christian countries.
A crisis brewing in Jerusalem could further escalate tensions
abroad. A dispute over the building of a mosque next to the
Basilica of the Annunciation, the church which Catholics believe
marks the spot where the Angel Gabriel told Mary that she would
give birth to Jesus, has sparked a planned two-day protest
beginning on Nov. 22 by leaders of the Catholic, Greek Orthodox
and Armenian denominations. It has also put the Pope�s March 25,
2000 Annunciation Day visit there in doubt.
Those threatened by Islam work to discredit it through the
shaping of the dominate propaganda against it, usually by way of
the media, observers say. In September, a three-part doc-umentary
produced by the British Broadcasting Corp. cast a supposedly
"unbiased" look at Islam in Russia, Black America, and
France.
With regard to Black America, the usual negative portrayal of
the Nation of Islam dominated the program beamed into France. (The
British government has yet to lift a 13-year-old ban against Min.
Louis Farrakhan.)
Widespread propaganda that Islam is a violent religion serves
to indoctrinate the public with a negative view, Dr. Boubakeur
said.
Thus, veiled women walking down the Champs-Elys�es, female
preteens wearing head scarves, and Muslim men wearing beards, are
all equally viewed as potential terrorists.
"This is not justice for one billion people who practice
in peace, who have no problem with the religion of others,"
Dr. Boubakeur said. "Islam is now a very great religion in
the world. Perhaps they fear that progressively, it will be the
first religion in the world."