WASHINGTON
(FinalCall.com)�The issue of whether citizens of the
nation�s capital should have voting representation in Congress, or be
exempted from paying taxes, got a hearing before a Senate committee May
23 for the first time in more than a decade.
Congressional Black Caucus (CBC) members joined city officials and
civil rights leaders to support the "No Taxation With Representation
Act" sponsored by Del. Eleanor Holmes Norton (D-D.C.) and Senate
Governmental Affairs Committee Chairman Joe Lieberman (D-Conn.) Their
goal is to "help educate the Senate" about the denial of voting
representation to D.C. residents.
More than 250 D.C. residents descended on Congress to lobby House and
Senate members in favor of co-sponsoring the legislation that would
grant D.C. the congressional vote. The District of Columbia, Guam,
Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands are all granted non-voting delegates
to Congress. Unlike those living in D.C., residents of other areas with
non-voting delegates are not required to pay federal income taxes.
D.C. residents pay more federal income taxes per capita than the
residents of 49 states, but they have no voice in how Congress spends
that money. More D.C. residents have died in wars protecting the nation
than the residents of 20 states, yet they have no say concerning whether
or not Congress declares war.
The Norton legislation is less about cutting taxes for D.C. residents
than it is about voting rights, a congressional source said in an
interview.
Sen. Lieberman told the hearing that the tax provision was not
literal, but "pointed and ironic" to evoke the nation�s founding
principles in the district�s behalf.
The denial of D.C. voting rights even has a bearing on the alleged
disenfranchisement of Florida residents in the 2000 national election,
according to Del. Norton.
"The voting rights issues raised in Florida in the 2000 presidential
election only served to spotlight the denial of any vote at all in the
Congress for D.C. residents," Del. Norton said in her testimony.
"If you want to get African Americans in this country angry today,"
testified CBC Chair Eddie Bernice Johnson (D-Tex.), "just tell them that
there is a majority-Black city anywhere in America where Blacks and
other Americans are treated as second-class citizens."
Some D.C. activists believe Congress can grant D.C. voting
representation by statute, just as it can confer statehood, according to
Jamin Raskin, a law professor at American University. In 1978 Congress
passed a constitutional amendment to grant D.C. voting representation,
but it died in 1985 after winning support from only 16 of the necessary
38 state legislatures.
The CBC also cheered an announcement of three federal lawsuits
surrounding the 2000 election. "We were very pleased to learn that the
Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department will file three lawsuits
against Florida counties and two others in Missouri and Tennessee," Rep.
Johnson said. "Although this lawsuit is very appropriate, it is long
overdue and we hope it is not just �window dressing.�"
�Askia Muhammad